Windows tip: File transfer with FTP

| | Comments (0)

If you ever have to move a large amount of data (by which I mean several gigs) around a Windows network, forget about using normal Windows networking and do it with FTP. The reasoning goes like this:

  • SMB (the main Windows networking protocol) is horribly inefficient at file transfer. As Sean pointed out to us, it's a presentation layer protocol rather than a file transfer protocol and it does a whole load of other things (named pipes, printer sharing, authentication etc.) plus it runs on top of NetBIOS which is in turn on top of TCP/IP. So it's not going to be particularly speedy.
  • As a result, using FTP often gives at least 200% of the SMB transfer speed.
  • On top of that, since the networking interface is pretty low-level within Windows, doing slow scary networking can often cock up Explorer something chronic. You know what I mean - locked-up share windows, horrific unresponsiveness, the whole of Explorer just deciding to hang and take your file transfer with it, etc. etc. U-G-L-Y. Doesn't happen with FTP.
  • Your FTP client will usually give you an accurate estimate of the ETA, unlike Windows networking which usually smokes a hefty crack pipe before guessing. ("3639347 minutes remaining")
  • There are plenty of nice freeware FTP daemons for Win32, such as the ever-popular WarFTPd, and almost all of them are easier to set up than IIS's FTPd - the simplest ones take about a minute to get going.

Incidentally, the best Win32 FTP client I've found is the open source Filezilla, which is lovely and free and featureful (it can do SCP). I only found it relatively recently, before which I was dependent on the classic FTP Explorer, which has a nice (read: consistent) interface and is easy and free, but a bit buggy. FZ isn't as good at simple drag'n'drop yet but I'm sure that's coming.

Leave a comment

About this Entry

This page contains a single entry by Yoz published on August 14, 2002 11:15 PM.

So this by you is a methodology? was the previous entry in this blog.

Fontly speaking is the next entry in this blog.

Find recent content on the main index or look in the archives to find all content.

Powered by Movable Type 4.01