Yoz Grahame's Cheerleader: At last, I understand the dangers of Google AutoLink!

February 27, 2005

At last, I understand the dangers of Google AutoLink!

Like many others, I had written off Dave Winer's recent obsession with the new Google toolbar. That was until I actually downloaded and installed the thing, and realised - oh my god! There are some really important points he's raised, and everyone needs to hear them right now!

"The issue for authors and publishers is whether readers know they're reading text that's been modified." And it's so ambiguous! Admittedly, in order for the web page to be altered by the Google toolbar, an "AutoLink" button needs to be pressed every time (it doesn't do it automatically), and the first time you press it this pop-up window appears which explains everything. Personally, I don't think that's nearly enough! A large claxon should sound, the screen should flash, and the user should get a phone call from a Google employee explaining the incredibly ambiguous and possibly-accidental button press. After all, the user might not realise that they had altered the content of the page if they were incredibly forgetful or stupid.
"What happens when Google isn't satisfied to add links to our sites, suppose they were to change the actual words? I haven't heard Google say they would never do that, have you?" This is an incredibly good point! Just because the Google Toolbar does something that is only helpful at the moment, there's nothing stopping them from making a later version do it automatically. They could also redirect all links on a page to go through Google. They could leverage their total domination of the search-engine market to provide completely false information about how big Larry Page's penis is. And then, they could use all the cash from their recent IPO to build an army of attack robots and mount an invasion of Belgium. The fact that in the previous seven years of market dominance they have done nothing that would even approach this kind of non-consensual content modification has no bearing on the argument! Sure, it would utterly destroy their credibility and popularity and decimate their userbase, but such a move from Google's decision makers would be quite possible if they were incredibly forgetful or stupid.
"It invites Microsoft, with it's [sic] virtual monopoly in browser [sic], to do the same, to the detriment of the market, and even Google itself." Gaah, Dave, as blindingly insightful as you are, I wish you hadn't said that out loud! I bet that the noise has attracted the IE7 team and they're now thinking, "Whoah, he's right! We control the horizontal and the vertical too! Why can't we just use our awesome monopoly power to, say, erase all mention of "Linux" (spit!) from the web?" Sure, they could have thought of this from the very beginning, but not if they were incredibly forgetful or stupid.
"At minimum it should provide an opt-out as described above, but we really want AutoLink to be opt-in." Dave speaks for all of us web creators when he says that the content of a web page should only be viewed in exactly the way its author intended, even if the user (by pressing the AutoLink button) requests otherwise. Even though the earliest web browsers included such content-altering features as "Turn Off Image Downloading", and that modern screen-reading browsers have to change the way text is rendered to disabled users, not to mention the approximately 10 billion other ways in which dynamic content alteration has become a vital part of web usage, (such as Google Cache search) all this behaviour is clearly wrong. After all, if a web author had to specifically opt-in to have their web page altered for any of the above purposes, the web would be much, much more valuable and have better integrity. It's worth disagreeing with those who decreed that the specific rendering of a web page should be ultimately left to the end user's preferences - such as the entire W3C, for example - because they might not have thought of these potential violations if they were incredibly forgetful or stupid.

So, there you go, folks! I'm not the only one who feels this way: hundreds of others agree! And the only way they could all be wrong is... um... nope, can't think of anything.

UPDATE: Dave responds, and I counter-respond.

Posted by Yoz at February 27, 2005 04:34 AM | TrackBack

Comments

Thanks for writing this. So much better than the post I never got around to writing, which would take the text, but replace "autolink" with "pop-up blocking". Imagine if Microsoft used it's virtual monopoly to include pop-up blocking in IE! It's a slippery slope, my friend.

Posted by: Rod on February 27, 2005 07:17 AM

I think somebody is replaying "The Best of Dave Winer" on scripting.com; just look at articles from '99ish in this search: http://www.google.com/search?q=%22third+voice%22+site:scripting.com

and replace 'Third Voice' with 'Google Toolbar'.

Posted by: Bdoga on February 27, 2005 08:51 AM

Thank You. This is just more proof that Dave Winer is clueless. He claims that a template for a website will change the world ,but complains when someone really does somthing that makes the internet a better place. I hope he continues to complain because he is only hurting his own credibility.

Posted by: Molland on February 27, 2005 06:19 PM

$100 to the first person to release a GPL-licensed Firefox plugin that transforms scripting.com into valid, accessible XHTML.

Posted by: Mark on February 28, 2005 02:27 AM

"$100 to the first person to release a GPL-licensed Firefox plugin that transforms scripting.com into valid, accessible XHTML."

And a tenner to the first person to do likewise, except that it turns every instance of 'Dave Winer' into a link to a Canadian pharmacy that supplies Xanax.

Posted by: nick on February 28, 2005 01:58 PM

Thank for the idea, Nick. No canadian v1@gr@ spam, but... http://groovymother.com/archives/2005/02/28/dave_winers_wor.html

Posted by: Rod on February 28, 2005 06:57 PM

What people should really get upset about is that Google will translate your page into another language without your consent, and there's no way to opt out of that. I didn't spend forty-three seconds carefully wording the English on my page just to have Germans mock the mangled translation that Google provides. Why aren't people outraged?

Posted by: Felix on February 28, 2005 07:40 PM

You should be flattered that people try to read your page in another language. In case you didn't know, not everybody speak english, yeah I know this planet is a scary place for people who find pride in speaking only english.

Posted by: Marika on March 1, 2005 04:42 PM

"$100 to the first person to release a GPL-licensed Firefox plugin that transforms scripting.com into valid, accessible XHTML."

It used to be that people who had nothing substantial to offer would simply correct the spelling/grammar of the original writer.

Today that person criticizes the validity of their code.

It's pitiful.

Bob

Posted by: Bob on March 1, 2005 08:17 PM

Bwahahahaha. Thanks, Bob, that's the best laugh I've had all day. There's a long history here, one that touches on licensing, openness, standards, discrimination, and general sociopathology. But I guess that all went over your head.

Anyway, my offer still stands.

Posted by: Mark on March 2, 2005 02:31 AM

In reference to your comment found here:

http://cubanlinks.org/blog/post/2005/03/01/Hyper-Text--Dead-.html#comments

I have only the following retort: technology giveth and technology taketh away. What I mean by that, is that people/geeks/users are being empowered by personal computers to manipulate content (like you did with your text editor) in ways that simply could not be (or could not be done easily) before.

So, yes. You can also take a newspaper and cut out all the ads and replace them with leftover Christmas wrapping. You can record American Idol off of TV, transfer it to your PC and use iMovie to replace all the ads with screensaver clips.

But if you do these things, and then republish them, uh oh. No sir. If you edit my page in vi, and then publish your new version, you've violated my copyrights as a publisher. Lucky for you, I'm using a Attribution-ShareAlike license, so you'd just have to give me some credit, but good luck with someone using a more restrictive license, or better yet, no license at all (just plain old copyright).

You see, I'm not sure that it matters that the Google Toolbar is on your desktop. You could easily get the same effect if Google simply provided a public, external HTTP proxy that you could configure your browser to use.

I feel that there is a different between modifying the presentation of information (fonts, divs, layout, images, etc) to increase its accessibility and modifying its content.

Posted by: Carter Rabasa on March 2, 2005 03:05 AM

I must confess, Carter, you've completely confused me. You appear to be agreeing with everything I'm saying, then the last line of your message bears absolutely no relevance to what you said previously. (You also seem to think that I say republishing is fine, whereas I said the exact opposite.)

It's possible that you haven't read my two blog posts after this one. Please do so.

Posted by: Yoz on March 2, 2005 03:14 AM

Mark,
Would a greasemonkey user script do? ;)

Posted by: Jeremy Dunck on March 3, 2005 12:36 AM

Posted by: OeadAzJkLo on January 23, 2006 10:40 PM

wine
beer wine liquor
wine rack
wine gift basket
wine club
wine gift
wine basket
wine cooler
food and wine
wine country gift basket
wine store
wine glasses
red wine
wine cellar
iron and wine
wine spectator
wine storage
wine online
wine making
wine of the month club
strawberry wine
wine enthusiast
book en in investing primeur wine
wine refrigerator
wine bar
wine accessory
wine country
wine tasting
wine of the month
red red wine
wine tour
wine cabinet
california wine
wine and spirits
french wine
buy wine online
wine opener
total wine
wine country basket
wine rating
napa wine
ice wine
wine shop
buy wine
wine chiller
port wine
italian wine
white wine
wine of the world
mulled wine
wine label
wine making kit
wine bottle
wine making supply
wine glass
california wine tour
wine review
wine note
german wine
fine wine
april wine
wine decanter
wine country gift
wine prices
type of wine
food world wine
oregon wine
australian wine
food and wine magazine
riedel wine glasses
wine stopper
mulled wine recipe
wine glass rack
iron and wine lyric
wine charm
wine and cheese
wine bottle opener
food and wine pairing
wrought iron wine rack
dessert wine
wine carrier
southern wine and spirits
sparkling wine
wine guide
sams wine
wine decanters
sweet wine
merlot wine
wine bottle holder
metal wine rack
monthly wine club
stemless wine glasses
how to make wine
napa wine tour
best wine
wine library
wine glass charm
wine merchant
www.azwinebottles.com
www.azwinebottles.com
http://www.azwinebottles.com

Posted by: beer wine liquor on January 24, 2006 02:38 PM

http://www.sdiy.org/pasty/pissing/l8s7zii62o/passing.html http://www.sdiy.org/pasty/toon/jqersqst/online.html boardsooneststyle

Posted by: thorough on January 24, 2006 09:03 PM

Posted by: fzYsuIKtHO on January 26, 2006 01:24 PM

http://www.suomifutis.net/pasty/incest/h6jrjr/incest_free_mpegs.html http://www.suomifutis.net/pasty/incest/e1ojgp/incest-boards.html http://www.suomifutis.net/pasty/mature/31928040/index.html distinctjournalmothers

Posted by: gelt on January 26, 2006 02:12 PM

Posted by: rFfSpIWHZX on January 26, 2006 03:12 PM

Posted by: aWqGnoKpUk on January 27, 2006 04:17 AM

Posted by: cfYlKAOwbB on January 27, 2006 12:41 PM

watches
watch
replica watch
citizen watch
jewelry watch
man watch
seiko watch
fossil watch
watch music video
omega watch
heisman watch
watch tv
pocket watch
watch free movie online
swiss army watch
football ticket
watch winder
nba ticket
cartier watch
price watch
tag heuer watch
tag watch
casio watch
wrist watch
gucci watch
breitling watch
watch free movie
invicta watch
kenneth cole watch
bulova watch
nixon watch
guess watch
timex watch
womens watch
automatic pilot productpage watch
hockey ticket
swiss watch
swatch watch
tissot watch
watch repair
watch music video online
watch tv on the internet
designer watch
celtic productpage watch
watch band
anne klein watch
world of watch
michele watch
nike watch
basketball ticket
atomic watch
lady watch
third watch
skagen watch
watch tv online
watch free tv online
woman watch
hamilton watch
rado watch
luxury watch
fake watch
esq watch
geneva watch
pulsar watch
discount watch
watch movie online
diesel watch
relic watch
diamond watch
night watch
elgin watch
raymond weil watch
dive watch
watch free music video
whale watch
croton watch
dkny watch
concord watch
vintage watch
watch battery
watch box
wholesale watch
iwc watch
jacob watch
santa watch
oris watch
watch cases
luminox watch
mickey mouse watch
market watch
watch movie
freestyle watch
watch strap
coach watch
longines watch
citizen eco drive watch
army watch
used rolex watch
gold watch
antique watch
military watch
http://www.azbrandwatches.com
www.azbrandwatches.com

Posted by: military watch on January 28, 2006 12:38 AM

http://www.topwebs.de/user/buchi/pissing/tcpcfpzs/index.html http://www.topwebs.de/user/buchi/incest/ujzdtzb/fam.html beckonframedrotating

Posted by: remark on January 29, 2006 05:20 PM

penis enlargement
penis enlargement pills
penis enlargement products
penis extender
http://www.online-manufacturer.com
www.online-manufacturer.com

Posted by: penis enlargement on January 31, 2006 11:00 AM

Posted by: YpaeQINOsH on February 1, 2006 01:52 PM

Just want to say what a nice site.
hard porn porn sex porn porn online porn get porn

Posted by: must2have on February 2, 2006 11:14 AM

http://www.villagedusexe.com/jeunefille/buchi/pantyhose/9hhhzho/package.html http://www.villagedusexe.com/jeunefille/buchi/toon/gwrzrbqa/academy.html garyhoodlumnow

Posted by: carried on February 3, 2006 06:29 AM

Found it looks great keep up the good work.
phentermine dating cigarettes casino adult photo poker

Posted by: CevenX on February 3, 2006 10:35 PM

Posted by: yoi on February 4, 2006 09:49 AM

Free sex videos

Posted by: Syed on February 8, 2006 02:23 PM

http://www.anzwers.org/free/bissines/casino/540314955/hilton.html http://www.anzwers.org/free/bissines/roulette/onr83b8h72/lotteryroulette.html clungglisteningkeyboard

Posted by: untie on February 9, 2006 04:14 AM

http://www.windtown.net/chat/messages/43996.html clothinggamessickening

Posted by: smooth on February 11, 2006 03:27 PM

http://zoomy.home.sapo.pt/pantyhose/rzwjuvk/index.html http://zoomy.home.sapo.pt/pantyhose/3sweg17/teacher.html afterwardsexcusepunishing

Posted by: straight on February 13, 2006 03:09 AM

Posted by: VNTfzhiMKB on February 13, 2006 05:03 PM

Pornographic character information...

Posted by: Febe on February 13, 2006 10:02 PM

Posted by: dede on February 14, 2006 03:58 AM

Posted by: Meduza on February 14, 2006 12:55 PM

Posted by: maxwell house coffee song on February 14, 2006 01:22 PM

Posted by: marck on February 15, 2006 01:25 PM

Posted by: miskas on February 16, 2006 06:20 AM

http://www.chochito-mojado.1rubias.com m http://www.colegiales-sexys.1rubias.com m http://www.mujeres-cl-oral.1rubias.com m http://www.fetichismo-tabaco-www.1rubias.com m http://www.enormes-pollas-xxx.1rubias.com m http://www.travestis-marbella.1rubias.com m http://www.telanjang.1rubias.com m http://www.brasileas-actrices-porno.1rubias.com http://www.porno-pule-pa-norsk.xxxpizde.com m http://www.pule-pa-norsk-porno.xxxpizde.com m http://www.porno-puling.xxxpizde.com m http://www.puling-porno.xxxpizde.com m http://www.porno-puling-i-familien.xxxpizde.com m http://www.puling-i-familien-porno.xxxpizde.com m http://www.porno-puling-i-fjellet.xxxpizde.com m http://www.puling-i-fjellet-porno.xxxpizde.com

Posted by: uiuiuuy on February 16, 2006 08:41 AM

Posted by: Eddy on February 16, 2006 10:25 AM

Posted by: ladislao on February 16, 2006 03:52 PM

Here we teach you how to discharge the best mp3 music as well as the last movies of Box Office.

Posted by: Baldur on February 16, 2006 09:18 PM

Posted by: QtDhuqcOIr on February 19, 2006 02:00 AM

viagra http://www.great-viagra.com

Posted by: viagra on February 20, 2006 09:03 AM

fcglc.com/
raginrecords.com/
juno chan.net/
raginrecords.com/
elainefoster.com/
loginnew.com/
fcglc.com/
loginnew.com/
sos tripassist.com/
ndctech.com/
jasmarr.com/
lilikoi.net/
bradleyracing.com/
crawfordlandscape.com/
ndctech.com/
hawkesbury.net/
loginnew.com/
fritidsresor.net/
windermereinc.com/
spoiledrottins.com/
nvdallas.com/
EwpyIdaOioRkWPbmK

Posted by: aoRWLfBeCM on February 20, 2006 10:19 AM

rlbailey smart sites.com/
elainefoster.com/
galleryangela.com/
mobile ware.com/
fritidsresor.net/
galleryangela.com/
metrorestoration.com/
fritidsresor.net/
nvdallas.com/
ctaolevents.com/
crawfordlandscape.com/
mobile ware.com/
ndctech.com/
orientcruisespecials.com/
sharpwebinnovations.com/
galleryangela.com/
bradleyracing.com/
advanced hearing.com/
kidstotots.com/
thepentecosts.com/
elainefoster.com/
xPnJrkjwgmUHAKIFT